Blog

The psychology behind a great customer experience

In today's fiercely competitive business landscape, offering an industry-leading product or service is often not enough. Customers are increasingly seeking more—more engagement, more responsiveness, and above all, a more personalised customer experience. Research has shown that 86% of consumers are willing to pay more for a better experience, so understanding the psychology and behaviours behind a great customer experience can give businesses a significant edge. It can also mean the difference between a one-time purchase and a lifelong customer. Here's how you can tap into human psychology to elevate your buyer's journey with your brand.

Understanding basic psychology for improved interactions

At its core, psychology explores how people think, feel, and act. These three pillars—thinking, feeling, and acting—represent the touchpoints where businesses and customers meet. By comprehending these fundamental aspects, businesses can tailor their strategies to meet or exceed customer expectations at each interaction.

The halo effect and first impressions

The "halo effect" suggests that our impression of a person (or a brand) in one area can influence our opinion of them in other areas. If a customer has a smooth, enjoyable interaction with a sales representative, they're more likely to have positive expectations for other aspects of the business, be it product quality or after-sale service. Businesses can capitalise on this by ensuring that every interaction with the buyer is as positive as possible, thereby creating a 'halo' around the entire customer experience.
 
This cognitive bias allows our positive emotions and feelings in one area to influence our perspective in other areas. For instance, if a customer is greeted warmly as they walk into a store, they are more likely to view the entire brand positively. This can extend to how they perceive the quality of products, the efficiency of service, and even how fairly they think they're being charged.
 
Businesses can leverage this by paying close attention to the "entry points" of customer interaction. Whether it's an intuitively designed website, a friendly customer service representative, or a welcoming storefront, those first few seconds can significantly influence the entire customer journey.

Reciprocity and customer loyalty

The principle of 'reciprocity' states that when someone does something nice for us, we feel compelled to do something nice in return. This is why small gestures—like complimentary gifts, exclusive discounts, or even a sincere 'thank you' message—can have such a significant impact on customer loyalty. The customer is more likely to reciprocate the positive gesture by continuing to do business with you or even recommending your services to others.

The importance of consistency

Another key principle is the need for 'consistency,' which taps into people's desire for reliable and predictable experiences. Customers value businesses that deliver consistent quality and service because it reduces the mental effort required to make a purchasing decision. When a buyer knows what to expect and those expectations are met, it leads to higher satisfaction and brand loyalty.

Social norms and inclusivity

Understanding social norms can also offer a valuable lens for improving customer interactions. People generally like to fit in and be part of a community. Brands that foster a sense of belonging or that resonate with a customer's self-identity can create exceptionally loyal customer bases. For example, brands that take a strong stance on social issues often attract buyers who share those values.

The critical role of emotions

At the crossroads of business and customer interaction lies a factor that's often intangible yet profoundly influential: emotion. The feelings that customers associate with a brand or experience can deeply influence their perceptions, decisions and behaviours. While facts and features often appeal to the logical side of buyers, emotions tug at their hearts, leading them towards trust, loyalty and advocacy. Here's a closer look at the essential role emotions play in shaping the customer experience.

Emotions drive decisions

Contrary to popular belief, most of our decisions are not entirely logical. Neuroscientist Antonio Damasio studied people with damage to the part of the brain that triggers emotions and found that they struggled with decision-making, even if their logical reasoning remained intact. This research suggests that emotions are indispensable in the decision-making process. When customers decide to buy a product or service, their emotions about a brand can be just as influential, if not more so, than the actual features or price of the product.
 
This doesn’t only apply in B2C interactions. While it's true that business-to-business (B2B) interactions often emphasise logic and data-driven arguments, the emotional undertones cannot be discounted. Stakeholders and decision-makers in B2B scenarios, though focused on facts and figures, are still human and are influenced by positive emotions and relationships.

The spectrum of emotional experiences

Understanding the range of emotions customers might experience can help businesses shape more effective interactions. Here's a brief overview:

  • Joy and delight: Perhaps the most sought-after emotions for businesses. When customers associate joy with a brand, they're more likely to make repeat purchases and recommend the brand to others.

  •  Trust and security: Vital for industries where reliability is key, such as finance or health. Trust can take years to build but only moments to break, so maintaining consistency is crucial. 

  • Anticipation and excitement: These emotions can drive initial sales, especially for product launches or limited-time offers.

  • Frustration and disappointment: Negative emotions that businesses must work diligently to avoid or quickly address. A single negative experience can drive customers away, potentially leading to harmful reviews or negative word of mouth.

  • Belonging and community: These emotions revolve around the idea that customers want to feel part of something bigger. Brands that foster communities or loyal fan bases often tap into this emotional need. 

Emotional memory and brand loyalty

Emotional experiences often have lasting impacts because they're deeply ingrained in our memories. Positive emotional experiences can lead to customers remembering and preferring a brand for years, even if they can't recall the exact details of their interaction. Conversely, negative emotional memories can deter customers from returning. That's why it's crucial for businesses to strive for consistent positive emotional interactions.

Emotion in design and presentation

Every aspect of your brand, from the logo and website design to product packaging, influences customer emotions. Colour psychology, for instance, plays a role in evoking certain feelings. Blue may instil a sense of trust, while red can evoke excitement or urgency. The usability of a website or app, the tone of marketing materials and even the ambiance of a physical store all play into the emotional experience of a customer.
 
Every business should aim to identify and address potential emotional pain points. This could involve simplifying a complex checkout process that frustrates customers or offering genuine apologies and solutions for service errors. Addressing these pain points can transform a potential negative emotional experience into one of trust and appreciation.

Implementing psychology in your business

Understanding buying behaviour and the psychology behind a great customer experience is only the first step. Implementing these principles requires a structured approach. Here are some ways to do that:

  • Training Staff: Educate your customer-facing staff about basic psychological principles and how they influence customer buying behaviour.

  • Monitoring and feedback: Use feedback forms and direct customer feedback to identify which psychological principles resonate most with your customer base.

  • Ongoing adaptation: Customer psychology isn’t static. As societal attitudes and behaviours change, your approach to customer experience must evolve. Continually monitor customer interactions and be willing to adapt and evolve.

In conclusion, understanding the basic psychology behind customer interactions isn't just beneficial—it's essential for any business aiming for long-term success. Tapping into customer psychology can offer you invaluable insights into how to engage, satisfy and retain your customers. From the halo effect to social proof to the power of emotional engagement, understanding the psychological triggers that drive your customers can give you an unassailable edge in today's competitive marketplace.
 
While understanding the psychological principles is crucial, it's the genuine human connection that truly amplifies the impact of these principles. Human interaction infuses authenticity, empathy, and a personal touch into each customer interaction, making emotional connections that resonate deeply. Customers want to feel seen and heard, and it's through real conversations, whether in-person or over the phone, that these connections are forged.

Read more on elevating the customer experience with a human touch

Read More

Related articles

Mid-year marketing check-in. Assessing progress.

Mid-year marketing check-in. Assessing progress.

Tuesday, June 18, 2024
Find out more
The psychology behind successful B2B sales

The psychology behind successful B2B sales

Friday, May 17, 2024
Find out more
Telemarketing – obsolete tactic or powerful strategic tool?

Telemarketing – obsolete tactic or powerful strategic tool?

Thursday, May 9, 2024
Find out more
What are you trying to prove? The value of a proof of concept

What are you trying to prove? The value of a proof of concept

Wednesday, April 3, 2024
Find out more

Our full range of telephone services

Data Services

Flexible Data Services

Data Cleansing
Data Cleansing
Clean, up-to-date data delivers better quality leads and boosts sales
Read more
Data Enrichment
Data Enrichment
Data enrichment helps you better connect with your target audience and delivers actionable insights, improved conversion
Read more
Email Opt-ins: GDPR
Email Opt-ins: GDPR
Do you have a clean, compliant, opted-in database?
Read more

Pre Sales Research

Drive your sales strategy with telephone interviewing

Pre Sales Research
Pre Sales Research
Arm your sales and marketing teams with clear customer intelligence and actionable insight.
Read more

Telemarketing

Telemarketing that’s personal, agile, smart and insightful.

Lead Generation
Lead Generation
A steady stream of qualified buyers
Read more
Call Handling
Call Handling
We can provide your customers with an expert, personalised service - making every interaction count
Read more
Appointment Setting
Appointment Setting
Successful appointment setting requires meaningful human interaction with senior decision makers
Read more
Lead Management
Lead Management
Improve lead flow and quality - turn inbound leads into sales
Read more
Event Marketing
Event Marketing
Engage high value attendees and drive registrations
Read more
Lead Qualification / Nurture
Lead Qualification / Nurture
Move leads through the funnel more strategically with our expert lead qualification and lead nurturing services
Read more

Sales

High-performance Telesales

Telesales / Inside Sales
Telesales / Inside Sales
Flexible, high performance transactional telesales and complex inside sales services.
Read more
Account Based Marketing
Account Based Marketing
Increase profitability, reverse churn and increase customer lifetime value.
Read more

Post Sales Research

Strengthen customer relationships

Welcome Calls
Welcome Calls
A welcome call is an opportunity to reach out to new customers and reduce customer churn, as part of an effective customer management strategy.
Read more
Customer Satisfaction
Customer Satisfaction
Gain a more nuanced view of your customers’ experiences through phone-based surveys.
Read more
Treating Customers Fairly / Compliance
Treating Customers Fairly / Compliance
An FCA authorised and regulated business, our expert team can help you meet your TCF compliance needs.
Read more